Center for Ecozoic Studies

  • Contact Us
  • Sign-Up for The Ecozoic Review
  • Home
  • About
    • What We Do
    • Our People
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
  • Publications
    • The Ecozoic Review
    • The Ecozoic Journal
    • CES Musings Archive
    • Ecozoic Reader Archive
    • Guidelines for Submissions
  • Education & Events
    • Education
    • Events
  • Arts & Action
    • Arts
    • Action
  • Library
    • Foundational Statements
    • Foundational Essays
  • Connect
    • Sign-Up for the Ecozoic Review
    • Become a Member
    • Make a Donation
    • Volunteer
    • Contact Us

Then as Now . . . Hope!: Christmas 1968 and the Photograph that Changed the World

by Drew Dellinger

Download Article - PDF

“If we are to have peace on earth . . . we must develop a world perspective.”

–Martin Luther King Jr., December 24, 1967

“Oh, my God! Look at that picture over there! Here’s the earth coming up. Wow, is that pretty!

–Commander Frank Borman, Apollo 8, December 24, 1968

Forty-one years ago, on Christmas Eve 1968, an astronaut orbiting the moon took a photograph that changed the world. As we remember one of the most heart-breaking years in our history, it is worth remembering that the year of trauma ended in triumph.

As ’68 dawned, the Tet offensive dispelled illusions of easy victory in Vietnam. On April 4 of that year, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., one of the world’s most visible and visionary activists for justice was shot down in Memphis, triggering waves of outrage and sadness as more than 100 cities burst into flames of despair and rebellion. Two months later, Bobby Kennedy was shot and killed in Los Angeles.

Throughout ’68, student protests and general uprisings broke out in Europe, the Americas, and elsewhere. In Mexico City, the Summer Olympics set the stage for the raised-fist defiance of John Carlos and Tommie Smith. In August, police and demonstrators clashed violently at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago.

This was the troubled world that the crew of Apollo 8 left behind in December, as they became the first humans to journey around the moon. Just as it seemed the world was falling apart, the astronauts on Apollo 8 took a photograph that would bring us all together, and forever change our image of the planet and ourselves.

In 1948, the British astronomer Fred Hoyle predicted that “once a photograph of the Earth, taken from outside, is available . . . a new idea as powerful as any in history will be let loose.” The earliest attempts at such a photo were not particularly impressive. The first photograph of Earth from space was transmitted by a US Explorer satellite in August of 1959. The picture was badly blurred. Other images were better but were never shared with the general public.

In 1966, a visionary college student named Stewart Brand created and sold buttons which read, “Why Haven’t We Seen A Photograph of the Whole Earth Yet?” Apparently Brand’s “Photograph of the Whole Earth” campaign played a role in spurring NASA to procure high-quality photos of the planet from distant space. In November 1967, National Geographic magazine published the first color photograph of the whole Earth ever taken. In the fall of ’68, Stewart Brand would publish such an image on the cover of his influential Whole Earth Catalog.

But the photograph taken by the Apollo 8 astronauts on Christmas Eve of ’68 would have a special resonance in the world’s imagination . . . perhaps because it was taken by human hands and not a satellite . . . perhaps because it included the edge of the moon in the foreground, thus providing the element of Earth as seen from the perspective of another celestial body.

A year before the Apollo 8 mission, on December 24, 1967, Dr. King, had stood in his pulpit at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta—his last Christmas Eve on Earth—and proclaimed that “If we are to have peace on earth . . . we must develop a world perspective.”

”As nations and individuals, we are interdependent,” preached King. “It really boils down to this: that all life is interrelated. We are all caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied into a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly. We are made to live together because of the interrelated structure of reality.”

One year later, Dr. King’s prophetic call for a “ world perspective” would be realized, as the three crew members aboard Apollo 8 captured an image of Earth that the world had never seen.

Frank Borman, Jim Lovell, and Bill Anders were the first humans to see Earth from space in its wholeness, as a unity. The astronauts were astonished the first time they saw Earth emerging around the edge of the moon’s horizon.

During their fourth orbit around the lunar sphere, the crew, scouting out landing sites for later Apollo missions,  was engrossed in photography of the moon’s surface when Frank Borman glimpsed something. “Oh, my God!” he exclaimed, “Look at that picture over there! Here’s the Earth coming up. Wow, is that pretty!”

“Hey, don’t take that, it’s not scheduled,” joked Anders.

As the crew laughed, Anders asked Lovell to pass him a camera with color film inside.

“Hurry up! Got one?” Anders, growing impatient as Lovell searched, repeated.

“Anything, quick,” said Anders again, and then, “Well, I think we missed it.”

Finally, Lovell got the color camera to Anders, but soon Lovell seemed to wish he had kept it for himself as he had had an excellent vantage from his window.

As Anders photographed the Earth emerging from around the moon all three men grasped the significance of what they were seeing,.

“You got it?” asked Lovell.

“Yes,” replied Anders.

“Well, take several of them,” chimed in Borman.

“Take several of them!” repeated Lovell excitedly. “Here, give it to me.”

“Wait a minute, . . . just calm down,” Anders responded.

“Calm down, Lovell,” said Borman.

“Well, I got it right—Oh, that’s a beautiful shot,” said Lovell, longing for the color camera. “Vary the exposure a little bit.”

“I did. I took two of them,” said Anders.

“You sure we got it now?” pressed Lovell.

”Yes,” Anders replied.

The crew of Apollo 8 had successfully captured an image that would alter human consciousness. There it was: The radiant, living Earth; resplendent in space; juxtaposed against the barren lunar landscape and the dark expanse; floating; infinitely beautiful; sunlit against the black cosmos; wet with oceans and alive with swirling clouds. The iconic “Earthrise” picture would later be called “the single most influential environmental photograph ever taken.”

That evening, the crew did a live Christmas Eve television broadcast, and up to a billion people around the world tuned in and saw the Earth as they never had before. Days later, when the Apollo 8 capsule splashed down, television reporter David Brinkley said, “The human race, without many victories lately, had one today.” After the mission, Commander Frank Borman received a telegraph from a stranger that simply read, “Thank you Apollo 8. You saved 1968.”

And just as Fred Hoyle had predicted, a powerful new idea was unleashed—a new era of ecology and environmental consciousness was born.

In 1970, the nascent “Earth Day” erupted into a national event with 20 million participants. Joni Mitchell’s song “Big Yellow Taxi” flooded the airwaves with its cautionary tale of trees in a museum, birds and bees decimated by DDT, and foolish humans who “don’t know what they’ve got ’til it’s gone.” On late-night television, Johnny Carson joked about a man fishing from a pier into water so polluted that when he turned around, “His worm made a break for it.”

In 1971, Marvin Gaye released his album  “What’s Going On,” with the song “Mercy, Mercy Me (The Ecology),” perhaps the most poignant environmental anthem ever penned. Gaye’s haunting lyrics evoked poison wind, fish full of mercury, radiation, oil spills, overcrowded landscapes, and dying birds and animals. How much more abuse from humans can the planet stand? asked Gaye.

In 1972, the first international conference on the environment was held in Stockholm, and the Club of Rome issued its ground-breaking report, “The Limits to Growth.” In 1973, the Endangered Species Act was passed.

Clearly, something had shifted.

But four decades after that revelatory “Earthrise” photograph, our precious planet is more imperiled than ever. Though the impact of the photograph of Earth from space is undeniable, we have yet to fully integrate its lesson.

As in 1968, unexpected surprises/breakthroughs may yet redeem us. May we bathe ourselves in the message of Earthrise . . . then as now, hope!

An earlier version of this essay appeared on Drew Dellinger’s blog.

Drew Dellinger (@drewdellinger) is the founder of Planetize the Movement and the author of Love Letter to the Milky Way. drewdellinger.org

Filed Under: Ecozoic Review

Get Involved

Join, Donate, Volunteer at the Center for Ecozoic Studies Membership button

FEATURED POST

Download current issue

_______________________________________________

NEW BIOGRAPHY ON THOMAS BERRY AT A 30% DISCOUNT

Columbia University Press published the first biography on Thomas Berry in spring 2019. The book was written by Mary Evelyn Tucker, John Grim, and Andrew Angyal. The book was released just prior to the 10thanniversary of Thomas Berry’s death on June 1, 2019. Information on the book and how to pre-order it at a 30% discount are available here.

Berry was one of the 20thcentury’s most important thinkers. He had encyclopedic knowledge which he synthesized in books such as The Dream of the Earth and The Great Work. His works were intellectually profound, inspiring, and evocative. Anne Marie Dalton termed the latter characteristic poesis. His presentations, written work, and conversations changed the lives of many people and gave rise to a historic movement that is continuing.

 


FREE ACCESS TO ONLINE COURSES ON
JOURNEY OF THE UNIVERSE AND THOMAS BERRY

 Mary Evelyn Tucker and John Grim, Yale University, are offering four six-week online courses. Brian Thomas Swimme provides introductory comments. These are featured as a specialization under the title:  “Journey of the Universe: A Story for our Times.” They are available in English and in Chinese.

This specialization includes two courses on Journey of the Universe and a course on TheWorldview of Thomas Berry. Each of these courses can be taken independently, followed by an Integrating Capstone course. These are MOOCs available on Coursera to anyone, anywhere on the planet.

Learners may audit these courses FREE OF CHARGE (with the exception of the capstone course). Or learners may register for all of the courses for a small fee and, upon completion, receive a specialization certificate. The courses do not have to be completed within the six-week period, rather, learners may take the classes and finish at their own pace.

Courses:

  • Journey of the Universe: The Unfolding of Life (film & book)
  • Journey Conversations: Weaving Knowledge and Action
  • The Worldview of Thomas Berry: Flourishing of the Earth Community
  • Integrating Capstone: Living Cosmology (only available as part of the specialization certificate—not available to audit)

For more details and to register, go to:

https://www.coursera.org/specializations/journey-of-the-universe

 

 

 

Connect

• Become a Member
• Make a Donation
• Volunteer

Publications

• The Ecozoic Review
• The Ecozoic Journal

AISO Hosting

Library

• Foundational Documents
• Foundational Essays
• CES Musings Archive
•
Ecozoic Reader Archive

For permissions, contact
ecozoic.studies@gmail.com. 

About CES

• What We Do
• Our People
• Privacy Policy
• Terms of Use

Search

Copyright © 2021 Center for Ecozoic Studies * Privacy Policy